gregorio
Headphoneus Supremus
- Joined
- Feb 14, 2008
- Posts
- 6,943
- Likes
- 4,157
Part of the discussion in the "Testing Audiophile Myths and Claims" centred on how binaural recordings are superior to multi-mic'ed recordings because they achieve (or can achieve) a coherent sound stage whereas multi-mic'ed recordings by definition cannot. I don't entirely agree with that assertion! While that assertion is technically correct, in practice we can create an illusion with multi-mic'ing which although technically is not accurate, is good enough to fool even quite discerning ears.
I assert that one of the main reasons why many believe that binaural recording is so superior, and that multi-mic'ing is effectively viewed as a recording technique developed by an audiophile anti-christ, is simply due to an apples vs oranges comparison. The comparison of "mix" specifically/exclusively for headphones vs a mix primarily designed for speakers. A multi-mic'ed recording, mixed with a more equal emphasis/consideration of HP playback, would be somewhat more of an apples to apples comparison but such mixes are exceptionally rare, so I present a short except below for your feedback.
If possible, I would like you to provide feedback on the following considerations:
1. Does it sound realistic, somewhat like "actually being there"?
2. Does the acoustic space sound coherent or is it a bit of a nonsensical mess? Does it sound like a real space or one artificially generated by a reverb unit?
3. What sort of space (real or artificial) does it sound like? IE. A studio, a cathedral, a concert hall or somewhere else?
4. Do you perceive the sound all between your ears (IE., a flat left/right stereo image) or does it feel more in front, above or behind you?
5. If you have the opportunity, what does it sound like when you play it on speakers and what differences did you notice with HP playback?
6. Any other observations, impressions or questions you may have.
This recording was an atypical situation for me but I don't want to discuss that too much at this stage, as I don't want to prejudice your listening impressions more than I already have. I'll explain after/if there is some feedback.
Lastly, I am providing this short except with kind permission of the copyright holder, please delete it when you have finished listening to it and do not distribute it, post it elsewhere, play or give it to anyone else.
Multi-Mic_Test.zip
Thanks, G
I assert that one of the main reasons why many believe that binaural recording is so superior, and that multi-mic'ing is effectively viewed as a recording technique developed by an audiophile anti-christ, is simply due to an apples vs oranges comparison. The comparison of "mix" specifically/exclusively for headphones vs a mix primarily designed for speakers. A multi-mic'ed recording, mixed with a more equal emphasis/consideration of HP playback, would be somewhat more of an apples to apples comparison but such mixes are exceptionally rare, so I present a short except below for your feedback.
If possible, I would like you to provide feedback on the following considerations:
1. Does it sound realistic, somewhat like "actually being there"?
2. Does the acoustic space sound coherent or is it a bit of a nonsensical mess? Does it sound like a real space or one artificially generated by a reverb unit?
3. What sort of space (real or artificial) does it sound like? IE. A studio, a cathedral, a concert hall or somewhere else?
4. Do you perceive the sound all between your ears (IE., a flat left/right stereo image) or does it feel more in front, above or behind you?
5. If you have the opportunity, what does it sound like when you play it on speakers and what differences did you notice with HP playback?
6. Any other observations, impressions or questions you may have.
This recording was an atypical situation for me but I don't want to discuss that too much at this stage, as I don't want to prejudice your listening impressions more than I already have. I'll explain after/if there is some feedback.
Lastly, I am providing this short except with kind permission of the copyright holder, please delete it when you have finished listening to it and do not distribute it, post it elsewhere, play or give it to anyone else.
Multi-Mic_Test.zip
Thanks, G
Attachments
Last edited: